It is highly likely that lately you have been rather distracted. As a way to get back to work, I will make a short public service announcement about two issues to which we should be paying more attention.
Friday, 2 May 2025
Line 5 (again) and Bill 5
Hot Water
BILL 5
Saturday, 11 May 2024
The Great Lakes "Goiter Belt"
The Bright Side: A Reminder
The clouds remain and I began thinking about how much we complain. It is time to remind ourselves that maybe things aren't so bad, or perhaps as bad as things once were. See, "The Bright Side" presented earlier in MM where I suggested that the musings of the philosopher Eric Idle can help us be a bit more positive.
Given that, oddly enough, I have never gotten around to writing about goiters, I will use them to suggest that with regard to health care, things are surely better, even if you are waiting in line to get some. The picture above is from the 1930s and it is likely that the swelling around the woman's face is evidence of an enlarged thyroid gland. It is also the case that she may not have lived near a nail salon since a manicure is needed.
An Iodine Anniversary
The lack of iodine is responsible for the enlargement of the thyroid and the diminishment of intelligence. In 1924 it was put into table salt to make up for the iodine deficiencies experienced in our area. As a salt appreciator and contrarian, I suggest we celebrate the 100th anniversary of iodized salt. Sources:
As with most subjects, you have good reasons to doubt my expertise, so here is what you need to know about goiters and iodine:
"How the Arrival of Iodized Salt 100 Years Ago Changed America: On May 1,1924, the First Iodized Salt Appeared On Shelves, Quickly Solving an Iodine Deficiency Crisis that Plagued the Northern U.S. 'Goiter Belt'," Ray Cavanaugh, Washington Post, May 1, 2024.
In the early 20th century, iodine deficiency was ravaging much of the northern United States. The region was widely known as the “goiter belt,” for the goiters — heavily swollen thyroid glands — that bulged from many residents’ necks. The issue was more than cosmetic: Iodine deficiency during pregnancy and lactation often led to children with severely diminished IQ and other permanent neurological impairments. And Michigan was at the epicenter of the crisis.The soil there didn’t have much iodine. Nor did the freshwater Great Lakes. And so the inhabitants didn’t have much iodine, either. The prevalence of iodine deficiency in the state became strikingly apparent after the outbreak of World War I. Simon Levin, the medical examiner for the draft board in Michigan’s Houghton County, observed that more than 30 percent[link] of registrants had a demonstrably enlarged thyroid, which could disqualify them from military service. In fact, it was the leading cause of medical disqualification in northern Michigan."
If you are now interested in this subject see: "A Grain of Salt," by Howard Markel and "History of U.S. Iodine Fortification and Supplementation," by Leung, et al.
There is some discussion about how iodine was introduced into the food supply and I would think that now both the Canadian and U.S. governments would experience some difficulty in convincing many citizens that such a policy was warranted.
The photograph at the top is from, You Have Seen Their Faces, by Erskine Caldwell and Margaret Bourke-White. There are many faces pictured and all of them suggest that maybe things are not so bad for us.
For more about Caldwell, see "American Folkways and Erskine Caldwell" in MM.
Wednesday, 20 September 2023
LINE 5 AGAIN
STILL UNDER THE WATER AND UNDER THE RADAR
Friday, 15 April 2022
Great Lakes Funding
I noticed the announcement above and it reminded me that recently President Biden and the EPA announced that $1 Billion is going to be spent on cleaning up the Great Lakes. Let's hope it is not too late. One would think that the water in Lake Superior would be superior to the water in the others, but apparently there are problems even in that lake which is farther from the big cities. The announcement was made in Lorain, Ohio and one of the Areas of Concern being addressed is the Maumee River near Toledo which is a major contributor to the algae bloom close by us in Lake Erie.
The $1 Billion is part of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and to make it palatable to some of the very partisan members of Congress promises had to be made that the result would be more than just cleaner water. The economic spin-off can be substantial: In 2018, an independent economic study from the Great Lakes Commission and the University of Michigan found that every Great Lakes Restoration Initiative dollar spent produces an additional $3.35 of economic activity. For older industrial cities, including AOCs such as Buffalo and Detroit, the study found that there may be more than $4 in additional economic activity for each federal dollar spent. A 2020 analysis of the Great Lakes determined that the region supports more than 1.3 million jobs, generating $82 billion in wages annually.
I did not notice much of a reaction on this side of the lakes. Perhaps most Canadians were more worried about the shutdown of Line 5, the rupture of which could really dirty the lakes. Canadian Press did take notice and this was found in the Toronto Star: "Biden's Billion-Dollar Cleanup Pledge Puts Great Lakes Back in the Environmental Spotlight," James McCarten, March 9.
"Joe Biden, facing a Republican reckoning in November's midterm elections, marked one year since his inauguration with a vow to get out of the White House and brag a little more about his legislative wins….So it was, then, that Biden found himself in Lorain, Ohio, last month, announcing plans to spend no less than US$1 billion on what he called the most significant restoration of the resource "in the history of the Great Lakes." The effort will target 22 of the 25 problem areas, known as "areas of concern," on the U.S. side of the lakes -- a level of commitment that experts, advocates and activists have been clamouring for since the 1990s and beyond."That's a huge thing, you know?" said John Hartig, a U.S.-born conservation scientist who's currently serving as a visiting scholar at the University of Windsor's Great Lakes Institute for Environmental Research. Hartig, widely hailed as one of the world's leading experts on Great Lakes remediation, grew up in Detroit before becoming the first graduate to earn a PhD at the institute more than 35 years ago. "Money makes this go, right? You need resources to do it, you can't just talk about it. So these are pretty significant investments."
The same is true on the Canadian side -- and hopes are high that the latest levels of ambition in the U.S. will increase pressure on the federal and Ontario governments to finally finish what they started.
It's happening already: Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault visited Hamilton Harbour on Wednesday to announce major progress on Randle Reef, long the single most polluted area of concern on the Canadian side of the lakes."
Sources:
This is the news release: "President Biden, EPA Announce $1 Billion Investment from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law Will Significantly Accelerate Cleanup and Restoration of Great Lakes: EPA Projects Work to Be Completed at 22 of 25 Remaining Great Lakes “Areas of Concern” by 2030, Feb. 17, 2022.
GreatLakesNow provided the Associated Press story: "Biden Infrastructure Plan Gives $1 Billion For Great Lakes Cleanup," Feb. 18, 2022.
"The lakes provide drinking water for 40 million people and underpin the economy in eight Northeastern and Midwestern states and two Canadian provinces. They fueled a 20th century industrial boom that generated wealth and jobs but caused ecological devastation."
For Canadian Areas of Concern see: "Great Lakes: Areas of Concern."
I live close to two of the lakes so Mulcahy's Miscellany often has material about them. See, for example, North Of Long Tail (Lake Erie) which also has links to some of the other posts.
The Bonus:
Here are the "Top Five Great Lakes Stories of 2021."
1. Canada and Ontario mark 50th anniversary of Great Lakes agreement
2. New partnership to publish community water monitoring data from Great Lakes region
3. Great Lakes communities to spend $2 billion combatting climate change
4. Partnership aims to bolster coastal resiliency along Great Lakes communities
5. Circular Great lakes launches to combat plastic pollution.
Sunday, 27 February 2022
Oddments (1)
In my last post ("A Gathering of Kestertons"), I indicated that I had to figure out what to call short posts, quickly posted en masse. I have decided to label them "Oddments" and produce some since I have written nothing at all for ten days and still have nothing much to write. I will try to do better in March, unless the weather improves significantly.
Line 5
Enbridge’s Line 5 oil and gas pipeline has been the subject of considerable debate. Opponents want the pipeline shut down due to the risk it poses to the Great Lakes, the largest body of freshwater in the world, while proponents of the pipeline have claimed that a Line 5 closure could trigger an energy crisis. But new research shows that a Line 5 shutdown is entirely manageable and that options exist to meet demand for oil and refined products (e.g. gasoline) in Ontario and Quebec without Line 5. This new research also finds that with a planned shutdown of Line 5, any gas price changes would essentially go unfelt by consumers. Our report summarizes the findings of this research. The full research paper is linked within the report.
Quote of the Week (2)
Advance Noise Alert
"With Sensors on Streets, France Takes Aim at 'Noise From Hell': The French Authorities Are Installing "Sound Radars" in Some Cities to Detect and Photograph Vehicles Making Excessive Noise, Which They Say is a Public Health Hazard," Emma Bubola, Feb. 21, 2022. Here are some sentences from beyond the paywall which you will not be able to surmount:
"Microphones on Edmonton Streets Listening for Loud Pipes: Similar to Photo Radar, Cameras With Microphones Set to Target Noisy Aftermarket Exhaust,"
The World Health Organization report is: "New Evidence from WHO on Health Effects of Traffic-Related Noise,"March, 2011.
Pickleball and Noise Pollution
Castrati
The Sad Tale of the Castrated Singing Boys | ||
Friday, 22 January 2021
LINE 5
![]() |
KEYSTONE XL is probably more recognizable to folks around here than LINE 5 is, but the latter is located closer to our homes and maybe even closer to your cottage. Line 5 is a pipeline that carries lots of petroleum products from Superior, Wisconsin to Sarnia, Ontario and it passes under the Straits of Mackinac which is the focus of concern. It is closer than you think. If the pipes there were to burst, the oil could, depending upon the currents and weather, end up in a Great Lake near you. If it is shut down to prevent such a catastrophe, people around here will lose their jobs and the price of our gasoline will probably go up.
Those are the concerns expressed in the article from which the picture above was taken. In it, the Prime Minister is asked for help since Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer has ordered that Line 5 be shut down, and it will be in early May unless something is done. Perhaps that is why some 'Yoopers' with long guns showed up at the state house in Lansing, since they may not have enough propane if Line 5 is put out of commission. Perhaps some Canadians would have joined them if the border had been open. There seems to be more concern on this side of the border about the loss of the energy source than there is about the potential despoliation of the environment. Those who favour keeping the pipeline open say it has been there since 1953. Those who worry about the environment say, well, it has been there since 1953!
The noise over Line 5 and the news about it will surely increase over the next couple of months as will the arguments. So, here are a few sources that will give you a leg up when the subject comes up. I will start with the article containing the picture.
Sources:
For the company view start here: ENBRIDGE.
There is a Wikipedia entry: Enbridge Line 5
"Prime Minister Asked to Help Save Line 5 Pipeline," Paul Morden, Sarnia Observer, Jan. 18, 2021.
Sarnia-area politicians and labour leaders want Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to appeal directly to U.S. President-elect Joe Biden to keep the Line 5 oil and gas pipeline running through Michigan, where the state’s Democratic governor has ordered it shut down....
Sarnia Mayor Mike Bradley wrote to the prime minister this month challenging the legality of the governor’s order and asking Trudeau to speak with Biden directly on the issue. Line 5 carries western oil and natural gas liquids to the refineries, chemical plants and propane users in the U.S. Midwest, as well as Eastern Canada....
This shutdown will put over 4,900 jobs at risk, and jeopardize Ontario and Michigan’s energy supply that we rely on daily,” Greg Rickford, Ontario’s minister of energy, northern development and mines, said in a statement, "Ontario’s four refineries ensure that Ontario, Quebec, Michigan and the entire Great Lakes region are supplied with essential products like home heating fuels, gasoline, diesel and jet fuel,” he said.
"Coast Guard inspected ship before Line 5 anchor dragging,"Beth LeBlanc, Sept. 13, 2020, The Detroit News.
"Economic Damages From a Worst-case Oil Spill in the Straits of Mackinac. Journal of Great Lakes Research, Richard T. Maelstrom , et al 45, 2019, p.1130.
Sunday, 20 December 2020
North of Long Tail
Lake Erie
Beautiful Photographs
Monday, 18 May 2020
Great Lakes Pollution
It is raining here on "Victoria Day" and I gather this storm came to us by way of Chicago where "two days of rain overwhelmed Chicago’s underground labyrinth of sewers Friday, forcing a noxious mix of sewage and stormwater into local waterways and Lake Michigan. At 2:30 a.m., the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District opened a sluice gate separating the lake from the North Shore Channel in Wilmette, allowing millions of gallons of human and industrial waste to flow with runoff into the water supply for 7 million people in Chicago and the suburbs." The Chicago River and its sewage used to flow east into Lake Michigan, but it was reversed over a century ago so the sludge would head west and then south. With the overflow, the stuff just flowed everywhere and some will find its way toward us.
That recent story reminded me of one from earlier this year when it was announced that London is also contributing to the rising lake levels. In January 68 million litres of sewage was sent into the Thames after we had considerable rainfall. While no one will be heading to the beach today, it is worth noting that we get our water from both Lake Huron and Lake Erie.
Bonus Information
Heading to the beach is problematic these days and not just in the Great Lakes area. Here is a headline from across the Atlantic Ocean: Apparently a "Massive Sea Foam Wave Kills Five Experienced Surfers Who Went Out During a Storm in the Netherlands. It was reported that "five surfers who knew the sea like the back of their hand, died after a huge layer of foam in the water hampered efforts to rescue them. While some sea foam develops naturally, the addition of sewage to the water is reported to not help.
Sources:
The Chicago story is found in The Chicago Tribune on May 16, 2020.
For London see: "January's Record Rain Exposes London's Dirty Sewage Secret," by Megan Stacey in the LFP on Jan.20, 2020.
“It’s the dirty secret of a lot of the cities on the Great Lakes,” said Mark Mattson, head of Waterkeeper, a Canadian charity advocating for clean water....
“A major city like London discharging raw sewage into the Thames River . . . that’s a terrible thing. We live in the freshwater capital of the world. We’re blessed to have it. The idea that we’re polluting it to the degree we do is really unacceptable,” he said.
For the story from Europe: "Five Surfers Die in the Netherlands After Huge Layer of Sea Foam Hampers Rescue,"By Lianne Kolirin, CNN
The group ran into difficulties at the northern harbor head of the Scheveningen district of The Hague in the Netherlands on Monday evening.
A statement issued online by the rescue service said its efforts were "complicated by the man-sized foam layer at sea and on the beach," while "strong winds and high waves also made it very difficult to provide relief from the harbor pier."
Police, firefighters, the coastguard, units from KNRM and other emergency workers were all involved in the rescue operation, in which a helicopter was used to try to blow away the foam and improve visibility.
The picture above is from: The BBC
Sea foam is a growing global mess: "How Frothy Waves of Sea Foam Coated the Coast of Chennai: Don't Play in the Bubbles." Atlas Obscura, Jessica Leigh Hester, Dec. 5, 2019.
Saturday, 28 March 2020
University of Minnesota Press
This is the fourth post in a series relating to University Presses. The first was about the environmental books published by the University of Washington. The other two were about the books produced by two universities closer by: Penn State and Wayne State. They both devote some of their publishing efforts to regional books. Penn State's are in the "Keystone Books" collection, while Wayne State has a "Great Lakes Book Series."
The University of Minnesota also produces a number of books that relate to our general geographic area. A short list of some of them is provided below. Full a full listing: UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA PRESS
It can be difficult to find good books. Here are some for those interested in the Midwest and more will be found at the U. of M. site.
This is being written during the "Great COVID-19 Quarantine." We are supposed to stay home and the border between Canada and the U.S. is closed. At least we can read about the places we currently can't visit.

The Great Lakes at Ten Miles an Hour: One Cyclist’s Journey along the Shores of the Inland Seas
2017 • Author: Thomas Shevory
A chronicle of travels by bicycle around the Great Lakes, combining personal observations with reflections on the geology, ecology, history, and culture of the region
Over the course of four summers, Thomas Shevory biked along the Great Lakes’ shores, absorbing the stories the lakes tell—of nature’s grandeur and decay, of economic might and squandered promise, of exploration, colonization, migration, and military adventure. This is Shevory’s account of his travels and explorations of the geological, environmental, historical, and cultural riches harbored by these great inland seas.

Border Country: The Northwoods Canoe Journals of Howard Greene, 1906–1916
2017 • Author: Martha Greene Phillips
Border Country is a collection of the remarkable, handmade journals from businessman Howard Greene’s early 1900s canoe trips to the north woods of Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan, and Canada. Reproduced with numerous photographs and maps, these journals are a window into a world at once familiar and strange, the wilderness caught on the verge of becoming the North Woods we know today.

Fresh from the Garden: An Organic Guide to Growing Vegetables, Berries, and Herbs in Cold Climates
2016 • Author: John Whitman
Grow your own vegetables, berries, and herbs with the fourth book in the best-selling cold climate gardening series
A concise guide, with nutrition information tables and hundreds of color photographs, Fresh from the Garden will help you extend the growing season to produce the best vegetables, berries, and herbs. It includes more than 150 edible plants and provides a wealth of information for determining the best varieties, harvesting techniques, and uses for your bounty—especially for cold climate gardeners.
Apparently we are not the only ones who know about canoes. Note the positive review by Canada's 'canoe man' and also that John McPhee was willing to offer a foreward - a good sign.

Canoes: A Natural History in North America
2016 • Authors: Mark Neuzil and Norman Sims
Foreword by John McPhee
Mark Neuzil and Norman Sims have written a wonderfully detailed biography of the vessel that made North America possible, treating it as a living, breathing personality. As enjoyable as a swift, steady, and smooth river, this is the ideal book for canoeists—the perfect canoe trip of a read.
— Roy MacGregor, author of Canoe Country: The Making of Canada

In North Shore Chel Anderson and Adelheid Fischer offer a comprehensive environmental history of one of Minnesota’s most beloved places. Compelling and accessible, the book will provide readers with a science-based knowledge of the Minnesota North Shore watershed so that together we can write a new, hopeful chapter for its inhabitants, both human and wild.
Lake Superior Flavors: A Field Guide to Food and Drink along the Circle Tour
2014 • Author: James Norton
From the founders of the popular food website Heavy Table comes Lake Superior Flavors, a celebration of food culture around the shores of the greatest of the Great Lakes. Author James Norton and photographer Becca Dilley take readers on a culinary tour around Lake Superior, hitting high-traffic tourist spots and cultural institutions as well as off-the-beaten-path discoveries.

A Love Affair with Birds:The Life of Thomas Sadler Roberts
2013 • Author: Sue Leaf
The father of Minnesota ornithology, whose life story opens a window on a lost world of nature and conservation in the state’s early days
A Love Affair with Birds is the first full biography of Thomas Sadler Roberts. Bird enthusiast, doctor, author, curator, educator, conservationist: every chapter in Roberts’s life is also a chapter in the state’s history, and in his story acclaimed author Sue Leaf—an avid bird enthusiast and nature lover herself—captures a true Minnesota character and his time.

The Lure of the North Woods: Cultivating Tourism in the Upper Midwest
2013 • Author: Aaron Shapiro
The origins of the North Woods vacation across northern Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan
This book tells the story of how northern Minnesota, northern Wisconsin, and Michigan’s Upper Peninsula became a tourist paradise, turning a scarred industrial countryside into the playground we know today. Aaron Shapiro describes how residents and visitors reshaped the region from a landscape of exploitation to a vacationland and reveals how leisure—and tourism in particular—has shaped modern America.
The book below about the Lost Mansions of the Twin Cities reminds me of a similar book about ruins closer by. See the very expensive and out-of-print The Ruins of Detroit, by Marchand and Meffre. It was produced by Steidl, the subject of an earlier post relating to, of all things, Gas Stations.
Once There Were Castles: Lost Mansions and Estates of the Twin Cities
2011 • Author: Larry Millett
The first in-depth look at the history of the Twin Cities’ mansions, Once There Were Castles presents ninety lost mansions and estates, organized by neighborhood and illustrated with photographs and drawings. An absorbing read for Twin Cities residents and a crucial addition to the body of work on the region’s history, Once There Were Castles brings these “ghost mansions” back to life.

The untold history of how the land of the Dakota and Ojibwe became the State of Minnesota
North Country: The Making of Minnesota unlocks the complex origins of the state—origins that have often been ignored in favor of legend and a far more benign narrative of immigration, settlement, and cultural exchange. It is the unflinching account of how the land the Dakota named Mini Sota Makoce became the State of Minnesota and of the people who have called it home.
There are even a couple about beer. Apparently craft brewing is not new.

2007 • Author: Doug Hoverson
Starting with its first brewery in 1849, Doug Hoverson tells the story of Minnesota’s beer industry from the small-town breweries that gave way to larger companies with regional and national prominence to the vibrant beer culture of today. Complete with a comprehensive list of Minnesota’s breweries—including many never before listed in print—and more than 300 tempting illustrations of beer and breweriana, Land of Amber Waters marvelously chronicles Minnesota’s rich brewing traditions.
And
The Drink That Made Wisconsin Famous
From grain to glass—a complete illustrated history of brewing and breweries in the state more famous for beer than any other
From the global breweries that developed in Milwaukee in the 1870s to the “wildcat” breweries of Prohibition and the upstart craft brewers of today, Doug Hoverson tells the stories of Wisconsin’s rich brewing history. Going beyond the giants like Miller, Schlitz, and Pabst that loom large in the state’s brewing renown, Hoverson delves into the stories of the hundreds of small breweries started by immigrants and entrepreneurs that delivered Wisconsin’s beer from grain to glass.
Sources:
All of the images and the annotations are from the University of Minnesota Press website.
They typically publish over 100 books per year with about 50% of them being devoted to the region and subjects of general interest. The other 50% are scholarly. They also publish around five academic journals.
For more details see this article from a Canadian university press journal: "The University of Minnesota Press," Pam Werre, Journal of Scholarly Publishing, Vol. 40, No.4, July, 2009 (U of T Press)
Post Script: If you had troubles as an adolescent you may be familiar with the The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-Adolescent psychology inventory also produced by the University of Minnesota Press.